Suppose he was a Muslim and recited an Islamic prayer.
Would you be so giddy if the student had been a Hindu and stood up and recited- 'We worship thee O Three eyed One, Lord Shiva'.
I would not have a problem with that if it were a positive uplifting message. The challenge for other faiths, is that, this is America, and America is 73% Christian, so that dog won't hunt.
Muslims, Buddhists, etc.; I wouldn't read or quote from the bible in an Islamic nation out of respect for the majority in that country. Conversely, Muslims shouldn't read from the Koran in this country, it's a Christian country. However, as Stillin said, if it was a bridge-building, positive message, most Christians would be OK with it, including myself.